
Fantastic Four 239
“Wendy’s Friends!”
Published November 1981
Writer: John Byrne
Pencils: Byrne
Inks: Byrne
Letters: Jim Novak
Colors: Glynis Wein
Editor: Jim Salicrup
Cover: Byrne
Synopsis
Ben Grimm’s Aunt Petunia arrives at the Baxter Building seeking the Fantastic Four’s help with a series of mysterious deaths at her home in rural Arizona. The FF investigate, along with an eccentric anthropologist, and determine people are being frightened to death by some occult spirits. At night, the spirits attack, the town goes up in flames, and most residents flee. Reed determines the spirits were testing the town, although it’s unclear why.

What’s going on here?
This comics is an example of how John Byrne’s abilities as a writer hadn’t yet caught up with his strengths as an artist. This issue looks great, but the story is an over-stuffed muddle, with too many elements that ultimately fail to deliver a satisfying ending. More on that in a bit.
The biggest development is the introduction of the legendary Aunt Petunia, and Byrne does a great job of subverting expectations with his young, hot version of Ben’s aunt.

What I liked
Byrne is at his best when he mines the classic Lee / Kirby run for story elements and makes them his own. He also gives us a bit more of Ben’s back story, which, after 239 issues, we still know little about. We are introduced to Uncle Jake, who we learn raised Ben after his parents, died, and then married his medical student, Petunia (and this isn’t the only instance of an eye-brow raising age-gap in Byrne’s run).

Byrne’s art is top-notch in this comic. Here are two sequences I thought looked great:


What I didn’t like
Ultimately, I think the story Byrne wanted to tell was too ambitious to fit into a single, 23-page comic book. Not only is there the introduction of Ben’s aunt and uncle and the central mystery, but he also gives us a kooky anthropologist, a precocious 8-year old, a child abuse subplot and some ancient, vaguely Native American mysticism. I was reminded of Tony Hillerman’s detective novels set on the Navajo Reservation when I read this and I wouldn’t be surprised if that where’s Byrne drew inspiration. But those books are told over 200 pages, and give the plot room to breath. This comic felt rushed, and the ending, where Reed pontificates like an Old Testament prophet, made little sense.

I also didn’t like that Reed fell into one of science’s most obvious traps: Correlation *is not* causation!

The child-abuse subplot was tacked on and dispensed with in a way that was far too cavalier for such a serious subject. Also, Byrne struggles to draw children, and they all end up with the proportions of toddlers.


And I thought the Baxter Building doorman’s Irish brogue was ridiculously over-the-top and unnecessary.

Between O’Houlihan’s accent, the age gap between Jake and Petunia, the questionable use of “holocaust” on the cover and Wendy’s abusive father, there’s a lot in this issue that feels off to a modern reader. I suspect an editor today would have a lot of notes about this issue for Byrne.
Overall
A rare Byrne misfire
The difference several decades make. This was a personal favorite for years. But you are absolutely spot on with the flaws in Byrne’s overreach on this story. I read in interviews that at this time, he was attempting to be quite concise with everything tying up in single issues. On further reflection, another issue would have allowed this issue to be more impactful. Still, loved the out of the left field depiction of Aunt Petunia!